my vote, Ritchey, he he he. just because he's the grand daddy of mtb. i like the look of the Trek Sawyer with its old school looking build with a tube under the toptube. But you'll need retro looking stuff so it wouldn't looked mismatched with new components, he he.
read some reviews, not all though, seems Ritchey P29 is winning for me despite its weight.
medyo mas pabor ako sa trek. unless straight yung top tube ng ritchey, which i think is not. mas seksi kung straight. i mean level. hehehe... alam nyo na yun. yung trek mukhang pang cruiser bike. or mas seksi dahil it has more 'curves'. hehehehe